Death Cab – A tale of too long and too short OR Amazon out of the dog-house

First, a Kudos to Amazon for rectifying the previous incident reported on this blog…when approached (for the 2nd time) about their faulty policy in shipping items altogether when you do super-saver shipping, they shipped my new Death Cab CD out immediately and swallowed the $2-$3 shipping at the same time.

Now on to my much awaited review. Death Cab’s “Narrow Stairs” is a dichotomy of too long and too short. On the one hand, “I will possess your heart” is fatally too long…8 minutes and then some, with the first four the same 4 riffs and piano measures, it seemed like Ben and company were just trying to satisfy its Indie faithful who wanted something expressly “non-mainstream”. Adding 4 unnecessary minutes to the track didn’t do it for me.

While one track may be too long, other parts of this CD are too short. In an Itunes world, there is simply NO excuse for an album with only 11 tracks. In my mind, for a CD to be a good deal, there should be incentive to buy it in its entirety in hard-copy. Tori Amos’ American Doll Posse had 22 legitimate tracks on it (2 were short musings), and over half of that 22 were fantastic. I think I have listened and re-listened to Narrow Stairs 10x hoping for 1 or 2 secret songs, some live-tracks, or SOMETHING beyond the 1990s album standard of 11 tracks. Some of their songs are fatally short too…No Sunlight and You can do better than me are fantastic tracks…but they’re cut short, the former under 2 minutes.

All this being said, my complaints on this album are mostly on account that I simply wanted MORE. Altogether, the album is fantastic. I think it’s more reflective of traditional Death Cab than Plans (which, for all intents and purposes, seemed written just to get radio-playability, though it was still good on its own merit). The songs are innovative, even catchy, and I can honestly say I’ve been listening to it for 5 hours straight today, without interruption. In short, it’s like an awesome concert you attend that ends with audience demanding 3 encores…only, on this album, Death Cab doesn’t give us any encores…just 11 great tracks and a unquenched thirst for more.

4 thoughts on “Death Cab – A tale of too long and too short OR Amazon out of the dog-house

  1. I completely agree with your review of Narrow Stairs. While I loved this album, ‘I will possess your heart’ would have been such a better song if it had started 3-4 minutes into the intro And I am not someone who doesn’t appreciate a long song! As a big fan of Pink Floyd, I can definitely appreciate the 5 minute intro. However, as you mentioned, Death Cab seemed to just drag out their intro in a misguided effort to satisfy their non-mainstream fans. Perhaps with a little fine tuning, they could have made an album that any fan would have been in love with, mainstream or otherwise.

  2. I totally hear you on that one…there really wasn’t much point to making that song 8 minutes long. I too am a Pink Floyd fan too, and at least their long intros have purpose. That being said, “I will possess your heart” is still a great song. Thanks for the comment!

  3. I agree, I love “I will possess your heart”. 🙂 But then I am a die hard Death Cab fan. Check out my blog about music if u have a chance…let me know what u think as I am pretty new to the blogging thing. I have really been enjoying what I have read of yours so far.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s